A watercolor illustration of hands resting on an open book of sheet music by the light of a lantern, with the text "Singing in the Flood Part 1 of 4" overlaid on the bottom left.

The Impossible Command

Mental Health
Faith & Doubt

The Bible has a sentence that almost feels cruel when you are drowning.

Sing to the Lord a new song (Psalm 98:1).

You read it on a Tuesday morning, in the middle of a long season of struggle, and the sentence does not land. It sits on the page like an instruction from someone who has not noticed your situation. Sing. What would you sing? With what voice? The voice you used to have is not the one you have now. The lungs you used to fill have spent the last year carrying something that has, more than once, almost taken the air out of you.

The old songs do not fit anymore.

You know which ones. The ones you used to sing easily, with both hands raised, in the back of a Sunday morning service. He has done great things. I have a hope. The victory is won. They were not wrong, exactly. They are still true, in some final sense. But they belonged to a version of you that does not exist right now, and singing them in your current voice would feel like a lie.

And the command keeps coming. Sing. Seven different psalms ask for it. Sing to the Lord a new song (Psalm 33:3). He put a new song in my mouth (Psalm 40:3). Sing to the Lord a new song, his praise from the ends of the earth (Isaiah 42:10). The instruction is everywhere in the canon. The people of God are, again and again, called to learn songs they have not yet learned.

What if the command is not as cruel as it first sounds?

The Word New

The word the Bible uses for new in these passages is interesting.

It is not the word for replacement. It is not asking you to discard the old songs. It is the word for fresh — the kind of newness you have when something has changed and the previous vocabulary cannot quite say it. A new mercy is not a replacement for an old one. It is the mercy that is, today, in this hour, freshly arriving.

The new song is what the people of God are asked to learn when conditions have changed and the old songs cannot carry what they need to carry.

This is the first clue. The command is not arbitrary. The command exists because the singer has changed, the world has changed, the season has changed — and the worship has to find a form that fits the new shape of the singer's life.

You are being asked to sing a new song because you cannot, in honesty, sing the old one. That is not an indictment of your faith. That is a description of your life. The Lord, who knows exactly what season you are in, is not asking you to fake the old song. He is asking you to find the new one.

The Question the Series Will Answer

But what kind of song could possibly be sung from underwater?

This is the question this series will sit with over the next three reflections.

Because the honest reader, the one with their head only just above the surface, needs to know. Sing is easy to say. The actual practice is not. You cannot, on a Tuesday in the middle of a long season, manufacture a triumphant chorus you do not feel. You should not try. The fake song is not what the Lord is asking for, and the fake song is not what the new song is.

The new song is something else entirely.

It does not sound like the old songs. It does not have the same rhythm, the same key, the same volume. It is, in many ways, a quieter song than the church usually applauds. It is also, in the long Christian witness, the truer one — the song that gets sung in caves and prisons and hospital rooms and 3 a.m. kitchens, by believers whose lives have, somehow, kept being lives even after the floods rose.

You are about to learn this song.

You have, in fact, been learning it for a while now without knowing what it was called. The breath you took this morning when you did not want to. The small prayer you said with no feeling behind it. The decision to get up at all. These were already the first notes. You did not recognise them as music because they did not sound like the music you used to make. But they were music. They were the new song beginning to form in a voice that has been through more than the old voice ever knew.

The new song does not require you to feel different. It only requires you to keep singing.

The next reflection sits with what kind of music this actually is — and why the church has been mostly mishearing it for a long time.

This is Part One of Singing in the Flood, a four-part series.

Part 1: The Impossible Command

Part 2: A Different kind of Music

Part 3: When the Sea joins the Choir

Part 4: The Body that keeps Singing

Share on WhatsApp
Share on Facebook
Share by Email
You may also find these useful
If the Lord Had Not Been On Our Side
Psalm 124. A song sung after the danger has passed, after the floodwaters have gone down. The whole psalm is a backward look — and it asks a question of us we almost never stop to ask.
Read Article
When Someone You Love Is Depressed
You want to help. Someone you love has gone somewhere inside themselves that you cannot follow. Your instinct is to fix. Yet this is often the least useful in the room with depression.
Read Article
The Psalm That Does Not Resolve (Ps 88, Part 2)
Most lament psalms turn at some point — yet I will trust, but you, O Lord. Psalm 88 has no pivot. It ends in the dark. The editors knew, and they left it. Part two of A Slow Walk Through Psalm 88.
Read Article